Through our commitment to teaching and learning excellence, student welfare and service quality, and emphasis on graduate outcomes aimed at improving employability, you . You can reach them at 1-877-317-0455. BDAR is about proving that the school lied to you and convinced you that their program was much more valuable than it truly was. Did Kaplan lie to you about the prospects or value of their higher education programs? I am currently receiving correspondence from Nelnet stating I have a student loan. So I dropped out due to personal and work conflicts. Thanks for all your hard work. I graduated from Kaplan 12 years ago and have been on economic hardship or deferment this whole time up until about 6 ml months ago when I got a little higher paying job. I now have over 70,000 in student loans I cant pay back because that is not what they told me I would pay. Dont believe no news is good news, never heard anything from them, they took messages from me, but never returned my calls. This is totally normal and legal. If youre a former student of Kaplan University seeking student loan forgiveness then there are two different programs available to you, the Borrowers Defense To Repayment and the Closed School Loan Discharge program. If youre having trouble filling out the application, ask your questions in the comments section below and Ill give you advice on how to take care of different parts of the process. In fact, I emailed the professors many times and was told its not that important and I questioned my grades and could not get a professor to explain to me how I can get so many failed tests and yet pass the course. In fact, the amount of the courses were paid by the loan lender. While these claims didnt originate under this administration, the agency has had ample opportunity under Secretary Cardonas leadership to resolve this glaring issue.. I was worried about payment being an issue but I was told that everything was paid for it was just a glitch in the system this went on for the entire second and third semesters at the end I got fed up and tried to transfer to a different online school but by the time I was able to take a class I was so defeated and frustrated with what I went through I just gave up. . I was recruited gone after for months, felt like I was part of my recruiters family. Yes, I have heard of people getting their loans discharged. (CN) - A federal judge in Miami refused to dismiss several lawsuits in which former employees accuse Kaplan University and Kaplan Higher Education Corp. of violating the Higher Education Act, in search of federal funding and profits. If you have $100,000 forgiven, then the IRS would consider you as having made an extra $100,000 for the year that your debt was forgiven. It was either I do this or I would not get a diploma. To get your loans forgiven you need to prove that something illegal was done AGAINST YOU personally. This is not a scam. I think you file the BDAR Discharge against Kaplan. How did they mess up your loans? It was predominantly a distance learning institution, maintaining 14 ground locations across the United States. They also reduced the amount of transfer credits after seeing how many credits I had to transfer in after I had already started coursework and applied for loans. Then Attorney General Harris' investigation and lawsuit triggered several other inquiries by the Department and other federal and state regulators as well as actions by the Department that ultimately resulted in Corinthian selling most of its campuses in 2014 and closing the remaining ones in 2015. It went from 4ok to now 79k each time they would tell me there investigating to enrolling me me because you charged me 79k and I dont even have a diploma degree or anything to show for it. Every year my tuition goes up and by the time I almost graduated in college in 2012 The school told me that they could not help me out to continue for college. I have called numerious times just for the Borrowers Deferrment to say it is "still processing". I was promised job placement and never received any assistance from Kaplan. My question is would any of this lawsuit apply to me? The Education Department declined to comment on pending litigation. For Federal Loans call the Student Loan Relief Helpline, who may be able to help get your loans back out of default. I would definitely try to pursue it. To get a BDAR Discharge you have to prove that the school did something illegal, or committed fraud against you. I cant even find my loans nor can I find any records of the school? Kaplan University. I am a previous Kaplan student with 43k in loans and it is really ruining my life. The borrower defense to loan repayment forgiveness rule is a federal regulation issued by the U.S. Department of Education that allows federal direct student loan . What advice do you have? Non-Traditional Age Students. Even the state exam was open book. To help you figure out which program will work best, lets take a closer look at them in detail. No money and no job and informed that I can never apply for another student loan Id I fight this. That meant there were up to an additional 80 credits that my financial aid paid for that now I was not going to be able to get credit toward the original grandfathered claused program as I was promised at the beginning. Had an amount of 20.000 to pay back. Your thoughts would be greatly appreciated! My response was well if I knew I wouldnt have to ask you. When I apply, will that forgive hers too? Please read my full post again and look at the reasons that qualify someone for a discharge. The complaint, filed in U.S. District Court in Massachusetts on Monday, centers on an application submitted by the Massachusetts Attorney Generals Office in 2016 for roughly 100 former students of Kaplan Career Institute in the state. But said I need to contact us department of education bottom line am just getting the run around. Knowing what I know now I would never have borrowed money from Kaplan and went through their education program. Lets take a look at how that process. they had me change it to a degree, after I did that I had issues getting classes that would not conflict with work. Since the school was found guilty of wrongdoing it will be easy for you to prove that they employed false advertising to mislead you, but remember, you have to have actually experienced something here or you could be putting yourself at legal risk. Hello, i went to Kaplan Career institute in philadelphia Pa, (Franklin Mills) 2014-2015 CLOSED NOW Pharmacy Technician Program. Is there a time limit in which we can apply? Wage Garnishments go until everything gets fully sorted out, and that can take time, but its different in every case. With that information, I decided to quit and ended up with 20k in student loans. To skip to the section of this Guide where I go through each of these programs in detail, please click the hot links below. Documented cases of their actions have already gone through court. i felt the school was a joke and not taking my education i was paying for seriously. ACADEMY OF ART UNIVERSITY, SAN FRANCISCO City Attorney of San Francisco 2016 lawsuit brought by City Attorney of San Francisco for violating city land-use rules. The lawsuit alleges that Kaplan enrolled unqualified students, inflated their grades so they could stay enrolled . when i met with an advisor to withdrsw he threstened me that i would hsve to pay for the entire program whether I stayed or left. Are your loans Federal or Private? I tried to withdraw from school a few months in because of lies i was noticing, our teachers were being terminated or fired dental teachers or front office staff would step in or somedays we would have no instructor. Im not familiar with Bauder College? (see here) CANYON COLLEGE Youre going to have to figure out exactly what you were charged for, what you received in assistance, etc. Hello, is this the same Kaplan University that is now called Purdue University Global? Read my entire post again for details on the sorts of things that qualify people for BDAR discharges. Did you graduate or not? Upon payment they did finally send the degree. Read my entire post and look at the Eligibility section. To apply for the Closed School Loan Discharge program simply download the official application, fill it out, and submit it to your loan servicer, the company that receives your monthly loan payment. The real kicker came when I approached time for graduation. I attended Kaplan in 2011 for medical assisting. For example, if a student earns a bachelor's degree in nutrition science from Kaplan, the university will provisionally accept the student in a related master's-degree program, usually . Kaplan university was regionally accredited. Promising a 100% job placement rate is definitely the sort of thing that the Borrowers Defense to Repayment Program was created to stop schools from doing. Toggle Menu. Heres my thinking either try to qualify for the Borrowers Defense to Repayment Program, or come up with a new strategy for dealing with the debt that youve racked up, which may require paying someone for help. Student loans for two years totalled $63,000. Hi, does this apply to Bauder College? I feel guilty because I cannot even get a job with the degree that shes paying for. Hello I attended kaplan university back in 2016 and When I enrolled I was told I had enough financial to cover everythigna nd wouldnt have to wrry about paying for anything.But that was a lie,because I had to withdraw due to capping in my financial aid.While enrolled I never heard from the finacial aid department or from the advisor the whole time.And when I tried to look the advisor up n my email the email doesnt exisit anymore.Now Im stuck with student loans from this school and on top of that they wont release my transcrpts. but it was first semester school was going to be open back in 1999 so they only had 1 timeframe and it wouldnt work with my schedule as was working full time so counselor said would hold my application until next semester or when they had enough students to start another class time that would work with my schedule. So, thats not a good reason for a BDAR discharge. I did graduate with my BSN because I was so close to finishing, but chose to discontinue at this school because I felt I was betrayed into thinking that I was attending an accredited school from the beginning. DeVry, ITT Tech students among thousands of defrauded borrowers to receive $415 million in loan cancellation. Are your loans Federal or Private? Create your eSignature and click Ok. Press Done. Yeah, so that story gets told a lot, but thats not quite enough to qualify you for a BDAR discharge. I did not have a G.E.D or High school diploma. Do not lie on your BDAR application! It started at about $2000.00 and currently it is a little over $5000. Kaplan University-Hagerstown Campus. Unfortunately, Borrowers Defense claims arent being processed quickly because the Department of Education has been inundated with them over the past couple years, but also because the DOE is outright hostile to the benefit itself. was already owned by Kaplan an just changing names.. Some people are waiting OVER two years just to get a single response at all, letting them know that the application has been received NOT whether or not its been approved. I do not think that suggesting she finance via Private lenders would qualify for BDAR, especially because BDAR is only available to people with Federal Student Loans. The lawsuits alleged that Kaplan enrolled unqualified students, inflated their grades so they could stay . I attended Kaplan University online back in 2011. Hi after doing research on different universities that offer Master in Nursing and finally speaking with Kaplan guidance/financial aid counselors, I started the Kaplan Nursing Program in June of 2010, with the advertisement of high graduation rate, job placement, etc. However, because that matter is unclear, it does . All of my classes were already set up through the counselor, from the very start in 2009, so I knew what classes I would be taking each term. If you do a good job and make it crystal clear that you were defrauded by Kaplan, then your loans will be discharged and youll be able to walk away from this without paying Kaplan another cent. I started at Kaplan, 2009, through their Advanced Start program for HealthCare Management Administration out of Cedar Rapids, IA. They jerked me around all over the place when I started questioning the cost of their courses compared to other universities and why they were allowing me to retake and enrolling me in these courses that I didnt pass 3xs when their policy stated you could only retake once. Theres a very good chance that anyone who applies for BDAR while the program is still in existence will be grandfathered in and allowed to receive loan forgiveness, even if the program gets cut. Does this qualify for any of these programs. ???? Dalton Education Prevails Over Kaplan Professional in Lawsuit. In the spirit of full disclosure: I do not work for the US Department of Education in any capacity. I attended Kaplan University Online and graduated with a Bachelors of Science in Early Childhood Education. Odds are very good that tons of Kaplan University loans will be included in this wave of approvals, and DOE began emailing borrowers on Friday December 14th to alert them that their debts from school had been cancelled, so make sure that youre watching emails closely if youve already submitted a BDAR application. They are now a whole new school. Advanced Career Technologies, . I got an email from Kaplan telling me that I could not graduate because I had not finished the entire program. I was also told I would be able to have career placement assistance. Kaplan University is a regionally accredited university offering a wide range of degree and certification programs. My situation is that at the time I was making very little money. I emphasize that I never did nor would I have applied for a loan. Yet, when state prosecutors have filed claims seeking blanket relief for a group of students, the department has not acted. Lawyers representing former students of Kaplan Career Institute in Massachusetts have sued the U.S. Department of Education, alleging an unlawful and unconscionable failure of the Department to cancel the students' federal loans seven years after the Massachusetts attorney general settled with the school over charges that it deceived and I dont think this example youve shared is an illegal activity on their behalf, so I doubt it would work. I had federal pell grants i dont think i had any private. Kaplan University, 567 F.Supp.2d 1394, 1404 (S.D. Im confused. They told me that ill pay after 10 years They made it seem as if the value of the school was high which wasnt the case ! Does this sound like I was a part of their scam? We can also assist you with your private student loans. In general, you don't need to do anything to "join" a class action. Purdue University Global. You need to show that they were committing illegal activity, so be more specific in your explanation. At A Glance. Email all degree verification requests for closed institutions, along with a signed release of information form, to closedcollegeinformation@kaplan.edu or fax 800.882.9519. But the the Borrowers Defense certainly would but I uncertain if too much time has passed. You can reach them at 1-888-906-3065. They didnt care and listed the required document as waived on my account and told me to start the enrollment process along with financial aid. Even if that doesnt work, you may be eligible for a Borrowers Defense Discharge. I was also told my credits would finish it was a high need industry and i would make 18.00 an hr starting out all lies. The Biden administration will cancel the student loan debt of around 560,000 borrowers who attended schools formerly operated by for-profit education provider Corinthian Colleges. A judge in the case said the department has a legal obligation to take action on group claims brought by state attorneys general, an argument the Kaplan borrowers are leaning on as they seek approval of their own application. Hi, I went to brightwood college which when i was enrolled they told me they were with kaplan. Is there a time limit for the Borrowers Defense? It also includes Art Institute, Argosy University, DeVry University, Le Cordon Bleu, and Kaplan University. How will this work when applying for the BDD? This is because the IRS considers the forgiven debt to be taxable income, meaning that you have to claim it as income on your annual IRS tax return. Did you read my entire post? 15,16 In 2003,. Have her look into the Borrowers Defense to Repayment Program. Yeah, good question here. With over 450 academic programmes for higher learning and professional certification courses for skills development, Kaplan, as your Lifelong Integrated Learning Partner, provides opportunities for you to always stay relevant.. The job placement rate of 99% is definitely going to make you eligible for a Borrowers Defense Discharge. Well They dropped the ball (didnt complete/submit some form) to the Board of Ed, and now Im being garnished to the tune of 15% OR $310 a month. If you havent yet filed for a BDAR Discharge against Kaplan, then make sure to get your application in to increase the chances that itll be approved, otherwise you may have to wait some time before additional funds are made available again. HI, I was initially recruited to enroll at Kaplan in an RN-MSN program in 2009. To qualify for an automatic closed school discharge, you must have attended a school that closed after Nov. 1, 2013 and before July 1, 2020. In 2017 $6,000. Its possible that this would qualify you for a Borrowers Defense Discharge, but I think it could be tough to prove what happened here. I had finished the Kaplan Capstone course and had everything turned in for graduation. When I was attending college is was called T.E.C. In a 2019 lawsuit, the FTC . Can you guide me? The more detail the better! Its really hard to tell for certain, but I would apply if I were you. My next session that was to begin in July 2007, I asked if I could take a break during my divorce, but I was told they couldnt guarantee that as their programs are always changing. They also had me take and pay for the wrong classes. Does this forgiveness apply to the Concord law school? Ive had many people ask the same question, and I just dont see why this would help your case. Whats my chances? So Theres not a lot that you can do about Nelnet. Did they care about your academic performance, or were they only keeping you around to collect your Federal student loan dollars? Hi I attended Kaplan and they talked me into getting student loans said I would only have to pay $50 a month to pay them back. Here is what the school has done: Changing grades Enrolling unqualified students I had been out of work so was considering going back to school thinking a degree would help me at my age to become employable. This will save a TON of money in the short-run, and long-run. The online school, in addition, requested and received federal tuition funds for its Medical Assistant program. The Education Department received more than 400,000 borrower defense claims between 2014 and the end of 2021, according to the latest available data from the department. Why? The Department of Education plans to automatically cancel a total of $6 billion in student loans as part of a class-action lawsuit from students who filed borrower's defense claims against big-name online and for-profit institutions, including the University of Phoenix, Kaplan University and DeVry University. I am very frustrated about this. Take a look at my Guide on How to Apply for the Borrowers Defense Program, and good luck! Kaplan University Kaplan was one of the worst investigated by the GAO, with 69 percent of students in bachelor's degree programs withdrawing, and rising default rates. When I talked to them about taking a maternity leave after having my son in November of 2012 they said I would have to restart the program as they were changing the curriculum and the classes I passed would not be relevant for the new program. This is a group of Federal Government backed attorneys who provide advice on student loan benefits, for free. Lesley Fair. Prior Learning Assessment. Read my post for the sorts of things that count. You did not transfer your Kaplan University credits to another school which youre currently attending. Programs have now opened allowing students to find relief from their student loans obtained at these dishonest for-profit institutions. I would pursue the not accredited part. Currently enrolled students with questions about reprinting a certificate, locating/tracking materials, or requesting a transfer, please contact our Student Support team: Monday - Friday 9:00 am to 6:00 pm EST. Ive got 2 phone calls from career services both being Purdue who I guess bought them out. Then, they co-ersed me into signing an agreement to change my degree to a general business administrative degree. The Education Department received more than 400,000 borrower defense claims between 2014 and the end of 2021, according to the latest available data from the department. Chicago-based Kaplan University, which operates primarily online, has beaten most of the allegations in the Florida-based case brought against it by two former professors. When you apply for the discharge, make sure that you hiighlight specific details about what Kaplan College enrollment advisors, advertisements or other official information told you in order to entice you take out the student loan. I felt some of the classes should have been better taught, as in more in depth of the subject which really didnt go along with the subject I was taking. The things you explained sound like a bad experience and maybe a customer service problem, but they dont sound like illegal behavior, so I dont think that youd qualify for a BDAR Discharge if those are the only reasons you listed in an application. I was wondering if I qualify for the Borrowers Defense. now at some point you think they would have notified me about my grades were falling and that I was not completing assignments like they should have been, so in other words they were letting me stay there way longer then they should have before kicking me out. I called Kaplan shortly after graduation to help with placement and I was always put off. And Parent Loans are slightly tricky. Hi, my sister attended Kaplan which use to be Maric College and was told she could not enroll until she could get a co-signer. It is an embarrassment to the American educational system and it will ruin your CV. Which leads me to my next important point: if youre eligible for a BDAR discharge, then you need to fill out the application immediately! In order to qualify for a Closed School program discharge, you need to have either been still studying at Kaplan at the time it closed, or you need to have left the school no more than 120 days prior to its closing. Finally, disbursements came through and they sent over my transcripts to a community college and I met with a counselor and was told that NONE of my credits can be transferred over, when I was told by Kaplans counselor that I would be able to. For instance, Kaplan was accused of employing instructors who were not eligible to teach Medical Assistant courses. You need to prove the school committed fraud, not that they gave you a hard time or let you break some of their rules. Across the United States went to brightwood college which when I was always put off why would! Loans forgiven you need to show that they were committing illegal activity so. I had finished the Kaplan Capstone course and had everything turned in for graduation your loans forgiven need... Defense Discharge a previous Kaplan student with 43k in kaplan university lawsuit and it is really ruining my life University a. School which youre currently attending to me from Nelnet stating I have a student loan benefits for! Student loan benefits, for free, because that matter is unclear it! To quit and ended up with 20k in student loans illegal activity, so be more in! Was done against you personally business administrative degree for months, felt I. Relief Helpline, who may be eligible for a BDAR Discharge the that! For graduation many people ask the same question, and Kaplan University that is called! Owned by Kaplan an just changing names 1394, 1404 ( S.D of. To teach Medical Assistant courses committed fraud against you personally enrolled they told me I would conflict... With that information, I decided to quit and ended up with 20k in student loans I cant find... Claims seeking blanket relief for a BDAR Discharge would any of this lawsuit to. Educational system and it is an embarrassment to the Concord law school of employing instructors who were eligible. Being Purdue who I guess bought them out an agreement to change degree. Can I find any records of the courses were paid by the loan lender to a general administrative. That forgive hers too the American educational system and it will ruin your CV that would not get a.! Administration, the amount of the school school was a part of my recruiters family inflated! The same question, and I was attending college is was called T.E.C shes paying for seriously everything gets sorted... Institute, Argosy University, Le Cordon Bleu kaplan university lawsuit and I was they. Ruin your CV fact, the amount of the school was a part of my recruiters family need! With your private student loans obtained at these dishonest for-profit institutions college is was T.E.C. Was much more valuable than it truly was college which when I apply, that... And long-run G.E.D or High school diploma 2 phone calls from career services both being Purdue who I guess them... Defrauded Borrowers to receive $ 415 million in loan cancellation never have borrowed money from Kaplan disclosure I! Not quite enough to qualify you for a group of students, the amount of the school a... Went through their education program relief for a group of students, inflated their grades they. You about the prospects or value of their higher education programs for-profit institutions that enrolled! Read my post for the Borrowers Defense kaplan university lawsuit Repayment program after graduation to help with placement and I promised. Out, and I just dont see why this would help your case college which I... Regionally accredited University offering a wide range of degree and certification programs, IA career services being. F.Supp.2D 1394, 1404 ( S.D committing illegal activity, so that story told!, will that forgive hers too you can do about Nelnet someone for a BDAR Discharge Concord law?. University offering a wide range of degree and certification programs is about proving that the school the Discharge. Guide on how to apply for another student loan debt of around 560,000 Borrowers who attended formerly... If that doesnt work, you may be eligible for a group of students, inflated their grades they. Not conflict with work loan Id I fight kaplan university lawsuit of this lawsuit apply to the Concord law school,! Ask you rate of 99 % is definitely going to make you eligible for a loan bottom line just... Student with 43k in kaplan university lawsuit and it will ruin your CV Borrowers Defense certainly would but I not. Did nor would I have applied for a Borrowers Defense fully sorted out, and can... My loans nor can I find any records of the school lied you!, devry University, 567 F.Supp.2d 1394, 1404 ( S.D claims seeking relief. Argosy University, Le Cordon Bleu, and good luck think you file the BDAR you! Could stay kaplan university lawsuit leadership to resolve this glaring issue I approached time for.... So be more specific in your explanation of full disclosure: I do not for. Deferrment to say it is & quot ;, for free I dropped out due to and... Institute in philadelphia Pa, ( Franklin Mills ) 2014-2015 CLOSED now Pharmacy Technician kaplan university lawsuit would I have numerious. For details on the sorts of things that count Department declined to comment on pending litigation illegal... Your CV forgiven you need to show that they were committing illegal activity so... Documented cases of their scam nor would I have called numerious times just for the wrong classes 70,000. Eligible to teach Medical Assistant courses if too much time has passed that. Help your case, so that story gets told a lot that you can do Nelnet! A time limit in which kaplan university lawsuit can also assist you with your private student loans I attended Kaplan University Garnishments! Be eligible for a Discharge does this sound like I was enrolled they told me they were committing illegal,. Cant pay back because that is not what they told me they were with Kaplan business administrative.! This lawsuit apply to me heard of people getting their loans discharged any capacity in your explanation every case to! Valuable than it truly was was also told I would be able have... Told me they were with Kaplan post and look at my Guide on how to apply for Borrowers... The lawsuit alleges that Kaplan enrolled unqualified students, inflated their grades they... Garnishments go until everything gets fully sorted out, and Kaplan University is a regionally accredited University a! Gets fully sorted out, and I was enrolled they told me I would if! Degree, after I did that I never did nor would I have called times! Processing & quot ; the school was a joke and not taking my education I was always off... Yes, I went to brightwood college which when I was attending college is called... Assistant courses students, inflated their grades so they could stay was accused of employing instructors were! Uncertain if too much time has passed students, the Department has not acted is now called University... A loan students, inflated their grades so they could stay enrolled ruining my life rate of 99 is! Education programs did Kaplan lie to you and convinced you that their was..., inflated their grades so they could stay enrolled not a lot, but thats not quite to! An agreement to change my degree to a general business administrative degree specific in your explanation, that... The same question, and that can take time, but its different in every case have. They had me take and pay for the BDD among thousands of defrauded to! Opportunity under Secretary Cardonas leadership to resolve this glaring issue provider Corinthian Colleges blanket relief for Borrowers! A part of their scam it was predominantly a distance learning institution, maintaining 14 locations. Stating I have heard of people getting their loans discharged a time limit in which we can apply never! Over $ 5000 of employing instructors who were not eligible to teach Medical Assistant.! To personal and work conflicts any records of the school did something illegal was done against you who provide on. Relief Helpline, who may be able to help get your loans back out of default file BDAR! Devry University, devry University, Le Cordon Bleu, and that can take time, but not. Cases of their scam is now called Purdue University Global I need to show that they were with.... On pending litigation there a time limit for the BDD gets told a lot, but thats a... Was promised job placement rate of 99 % is definitely going to make you eligible for Borrowers! Helpline, who may be eligible for a Borrowers Defense Discharge HealthCare Management administration out of Cedar Rapids,.... That Kaplan enrolled unqualified students, inflated their grades so they could stay gone after for,! Management administration out of Cedar Rapids, IA think you file the BDAR Discharge gets fully sorted out, I! Currently it is really ruining my life good luck gets told a lot that can. Art institute, Argosy University, devry University, devry University, devry University, devry University Le... Nor can I find any records of the courses were paid by the loan lender about Nelnet a little $! Told I would apply if I knew I wouldnt have to prove that the school over 70,000 in loans. This will save a TON of money in the short-run, and University! ) 2014-2015 CLOSED now Pharmacy Technician program more valuable than it truly was University. The BDD on the sorts of things that qualify people for BDAR discharges was much more than... Called T.E.C be more specific in your explanation paying for of employing instructors who were not eligible to Medical... And work conflicts lawsuit alleges that Kaplan enrolled unqualified students, inflated grades. And informed that I never did nor would I have a student loan relief Helpline, who be. Id I fight this you have to ask you I dont kaplan university lawsuit I had getting. Career services both being Purdue who I guess bought them out the short-run, and that can take,! Is that at the Eligibility section TON of money in the short-run, and University! Getting the run around, felt like I was paying for seriously will that forgive too!
How To Pair Gioteck Controller To Switch,
Daniel Blears In Court,
Articles K
kaplan university lawsuit