When we sent the gun to S&W for examination, detonation was their determination, likely due to a light handload. Despite the fact that some people dont like Taurus guns, I still like my Taurus 617Ti. Trigger was good out of the box, after about 5,000 rounds it was outstanding! Answer (1 of 16): A detailed answer would require far more time than I can spare, but I have what I believe is a valid, solid opinion, and will attempt to list my reasons. The best pistol is having both pistols. Granted the 686 is a fine weapon and probably should've beat out the Ruger Redhawk at #6 but that is the choice of the author. But it's in my safe and I carry a semi auto due to available firepower with a .357 Sig - in a 226 - can't beat the ballistics Really great article. Preferably the 3" Wiley Clapp version. My first handgun was a Colt revolver (Trooper Mk III in .357) and it was a beefy piece. the slickness and fitting of a GP100 to a Python is even more fruitless than people who compare GP's to S&W 586's and 686's. The only thing they have in common are they are .357 revolvers. To simulate the carry .357 Magnum ammo, use .38 Special +P or low velocity .357 Magnum ammo. Ill stack mine up to any revolver out there. Colt Python Vs Smith and Wesson 686 - Larry Reidy Colt Python Vs Smith and Wesson 686 Posted on April 20, 2021 by Larry Reidy | Posted in: Uncategorized Hickok45 has an excellent video on these two great revolvers. It has a 2.125-inch underlug barrel and exposed hammer with black synthetic grips that wear well. Black powder occupies a far greater volume than smokeless. Just stopping a threat does not mean the gun has "proven Stopping Power" - too big to carry; and too much for me to handle. There is one correction you might care to make in the interest of accurate history, though. I keep those at home. Jan 30, 2020. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Effective. The extra 1/8" in case is purely and simply so that one cannot chamber a .357 cartridge in a revolver chambered for 38 special. I did take it in to get cleaned up , but it runs very well . You get what you pay for and this new version is a Python in name only. New Colt Python Vs. 686 GoldenWebb 54.1K subscribers Join 18K views 3 years ago #GoldenWebb Support the channel by subscribing to Big Daddy Unlimited! The Security Six has the best reviews of all 357 Mag. Type your new password and hit button below to confirm it. The barrels are both 1:14 LH twist with 6 grooves. And I had to have a S&W, but still looking for a "Registered Magnum" model. We'll only use the information provided according to our privacy policy. A full power 158gr. I first examined one of these odd-looking wheelguns as a candidate for PPC (Police Pistol. I have a couple blackhawks and they are fine guns that will last a lifetime super strong. It has a 2.125-inch underlug barrel and exposed hammer with black synthetic grips that wear well. I am a highly prejudicated in favor of larger caliber revolvers (smallest being a S&W .38 w/ 4.5" barrel) for what i call the three H's- Hunt, Hit, and Hurt- bringing down food, accuracy/proficiencey with the firearm (obviously needed for H1and H2) and puttin the hurt on evildoers up to no good (Home invasion, self and others personal safety etc) I've never had one jam, stovepipe, fail to feed etc My 357 of choice is a Ruger Blkhwk w/ 6.5 bbl I also own two 41 mags, a Ruger and a S&W ,both have 8 3/8" bbls- slight edge to the Smith for quicker reloading- 2 Colt 45 long 6" and 1 has a 4.5 AND just for shits n giggles 2 Heritage Ruffies a 6.5 and a 9 inch both with 22lr and 22 mag cylinders Not to worried bout the ol' CCL aspect I enjoy the article and the other replies to each to their own. The King Cobra has a perfect balance of size, weight, and barrel length that results in a great shooter that isn't cumbersome to carry. These are two very fine guns and either one will make a fine choice. I have owed both, so here is my two cents on them. Try one! What about the Rhino? I disagree 8 shot sounds nice, but heavy and clunky so in practicality the 686+(7 shot) is much easier to carry not to mention the difference in price, the 627 just doesnt have enough to justify the cost difference over the 686+.. most forum readers tend to agree. SW are fantastic guns, just never loved the short hammer pull, again, not what I was used to. One also must consider whether today's .357 Magnum revolvers are as good as or worse than the giants upon whose shoulders they stand. This gun is FABULOUS! Striker-Fired Compact Pistol Chambered in 45 ACP . So work of art for a operating gun not a collector that sits and never ever will it get packed ! Model 19 Carry Comp 3" Ruger . and have never had a problem with any of them. You left out the very best .357 Magnum revolver: the Smith and Wesson 686 plus. I have an old model 19 and just recently started shooting again. no gun is a must as its all in the opinion of the person who makes the liks. The machines that produced them were run by humans, and not by computers. The Test Guns. I too have been a big fan of Taurus. Back in the day, it was, by far, the absolute best out-of-the-box revolver on the marketPERIOD!! I still regularly take it to the range and it is very accurate and can handle a heavy load with no problem. any review giving is a matter of opinion of the person giving it. I couldnt put the Rhino down fast enough. I shoot .38 +P ammo for practice. Over the years I have owned most of the 357 Mag Revolvers you listed and since I reload I have put a lot of lead through them. You can swap cylinders between .357 and 9mm, and recoil is pretty gentle thanks to the design. Small frame revolvers usually weigh between 12 ounces and 2 pounds when empty. It has been for going one 30 or 40 years. You can also order a 3 or 7-inch barrel if you prefer. have the s&w 627 with the 2.635 inch looking at getting the 327 trr8 or the r8 in the 5inch i think it is mot sure yet and u should change the taurus to the 608 from the 66ss same size just 8 shots. It features a fixed rear sight, brass bead front sight, and Hogue Overmolded rubber grips. Thank you. And a Ruger BH ss 6 1/2 brl. Love all of them. The N frame is the largest frame used for the S&W .357 Magnum revolvers. (Never did get rid of that guy's flinch, but he retired as a major anyway.) . When selecting a .357 Magnum revolver, keep in mind frame size and capacity so you can be sure to pick the one thats perfect for you. Featuring an 8-shot cylinder and a factory-tuned action, this revolver is hard to beat. We'll send you the latest guides and training tips geared And when this article was written S&W were producing their new K frames that have been reinforced through the forcing cone area. Barrel lengths differ based on which model but most float between 2 and 4 inches. JMHO, full lugs seem easier to aim. 3. For target practice, I still recommend using .38 Special ammo to save money. Since more of the bullets mass is outside the cartridge, there is more room for powder in the cartridge. It will list just about every 357 magnum, new and used for you to look at. towards your level. The development of the .357 Magnum cartridge was shepherded by some of the most brilliant minds of the era. Thanks for the rec, Colin! I love that gun! Be sure to read all about the K6s in our review! I had heard at one point that the Python's have the most moving parts of any revolver on the market which is one reason for their feel. The Model 627 also brings a large trigger and hammer and adjustable rear sight with a gold bead front sight. For a small person, it fits me like a glove and is a beast that with the right ammo can do any kind of shooting you want to do. Colt revolver fanatics love to tout the Python but Colt walked away from that market years ago leaving S&W as the de facto standard. Again, do we have to state so emphatically, that the list is the opinion of the author. Ruger also offers a 4.2-inch model that sports a fiber optic front sight and adjustable rear sight. If one wants to put a "Super Tune" into both guns the Colt will have a lighter double action pull down around 6 pounds; single action will be somewhat lighter in the Smith. I put the 2 and 1/2 inch barrel on, loaded with .357 and with no hearing protection, pulled the trigger. Colt recently released a new 2020 Colt Python, and after sixteen years of anticipation, the demand for this beast was quite high. The King Cobra is a medium-frame 6-shot revolver with a 3-inch barrel, sporting a brushed stainless steel finish. 1. I shoot exclusively reloads now, but 357 or 38spc both run excellent in it. 2020 Python vs S&W 686 Watch on CZ Scorpion EVO 3 S1 Pistol batesvilleshooter.com You probably also know it as the gun that won the West. The Colt has a more personal story. The KC is what Colt called a MK V action and they made a few Troopers featuring this action before they came out with the King. the smith is twice the shooter the python ever dreamed of being, and for about a third the price. My daughter liked it and now she is downright deadly with it. Hi, just got the 357 Magnum bug. The new 6-inch barrel Colt Python has an unloaded weight of 46-ounces and an overall length of 11.5-inches. I also owned a 3" SP101. I was lucky enough to grow up with .357s available to shoot and since then it has always been my go to cartridge. Possibly a coincidence but all of my favorite magnums are heavy barrel full lug. So, if youre looking for a .357 magnum, check out this revolver. Tried a few different grips but not a lot of selection for that model, but it deserves to be on there being the first revolver with the transfer bar. You have the date incorrect on the release of the Ruger GP100. The Colt has an eight-pound double-action pull. Although this is the lightest revolver on the list, the high build quality and excellent shootability are apparent in the K6s. Guess I just love that Wesson name. Taurus model 608 Eight shot .357 magnum 4 barrel stainless. Used a S&W 6" 686 for years in U.S.P.S.A matches even had a compensator milled in it, the hotter the load the less the muzzle would rise. Thank y'all! Thanks! It handles .357 mag with a 2 inch barrel like a beast. Smith and Wesson K frames are obsolete but a $2500 used python is not? Best .357 Revolvers: Top Picks for Gun Enthusiasts and First-Time Gun Owners. One area where the Ruger GP100 and the S&W 686 absolutely smoke the Colt Python is availability of aftermarket parts. I am experienced shooter. I just still don't understand why they are suddenly worth so much money. The single action pull comes in at about three pounds while the 686 is 10 pounds in double action and the single action pull is about 2.5 pounds. This came after S&W learned that extensive use of hot magnum loads through .357 Magnum chambered K frames (models 13, 19, 65, 66) dished out more battering than the smaller guns could handle. That's it. vs. Sig Sauer . In cooler carry my Windy in what you might call "semi-open" OWB carry, under a jacket or vest. I have a Taurus Tracker model 692, multi-caliber. Also comes with holster and 2 speed loaders Great gun in great condition. I have owned 2 Model 66s (6 shot), with 4 barrels and a 2 Model 606 (not 605). Not much else to say. It's made to shoot. For general target practice, shoot. umm your going to deep with all that. There is no "proven stopping power" for a particular caliber gun. When I hear .357 Magnum, I immediately think, "COLT PYTHON"!!! Strong and very accurate. G26 Gen4 . I have a Security Six that I like and a K6s 3" DASA that I love. S&W Model 66 Lots of great guns and points here but as with any beat of list, you like what you like. The problem with reviews of the BEST .357 Magnum revolvers is that the reviewers tend to be in the pockets of the advertisers. There was (and is) PLENTY of volume in the 38 special case since the 38 spl was originally a black powder cartridge and the .357 was developed using denser smokeless powder. Shes a beauty and she cooks! The SP-101 isa 5-shot DA/SA .357 Magnum available in stainless steel or blued finishes. The K6s is soooooo much nicer! 357 Magnum Revolvers do not have "Proven Stopping Power". Although Colt has yet to grace us with a blued version of the Python, they have released two separate barrel lengths, 6 and 4.25. The Ruger GP-100 is a 6 or 7-shot .357 Magnum revolver with a DA/SA medium frame revolver. We all have our favorites and that's ok. In fact I ordered 2 S&W 640 Pro series revolvers but did not take possession of one of them because it kept locking/jamming up while cycling PLUS the cylinder HAD TO BE FORCED OPEN! I too have a GP 100 and a S&W 686 Plus. But many reviewers pass over the facts that the earlier Security-Six also was incredibly sturdy, plus it was lighter. I know a lot of people would disagree, but of all the snub noses, 357 or 38 special I have shot, the newest Taurus 605 is the one I bought and would buy again. Chiappa Rhino should be on this list. The price was very affordable too. It also shoots 38 and 9mm with another cylinder. Also, glad you at least mentioned Taurus even though they didn't make the list. The 2.25-inch and 3-inch models offer synthetic black grips, front ramp sight, and fixed rear sight. Series. The action is super smooth. for a front blade sight and fixed rear sight. Striker-Fired Subcompact Pistol Chambered in 9mm Luger . Great article. Ive owned a Ruger GP-100 since the late 80s-first handgun I ever purchased and 100% agree with your points on the gun and versatile ammo options in general. I have one, 6 inch barrel, don't shoot with my Dan Wesson that also has a 6 inch barrel. You will get better accuracy in rapid-fire on the second and third shots. As an example, I do happen to like the earlier 6 shot 686s, but dont care much for the heavier 7 shooters. Check out our picks for the best .38 Special & .357 Magnum ammo for home defense, target shooting, and hunting. The Colt Python cost 50-100% more than a comparable Smith and Wesson revolver, and was arguably more fragile. My main gripe is that, to me, the Colt's double-action trigger seems to get heavier as I pull the trigger, while the S&W seems more consistent from start to finish.may be my imagination, but that's what I feel. Finally, theres the J Frameprobably one of the most popular styles of revolvers. Printing is a challenge. I have never heard anyone in my life refer to a gp100 as anything more than sufficient. Overall, Colt's single actions have been surpassed by their clones for a long while now. It drove the market price up about $200 over the last Python they released, but maybe we can chalk that up to inflation. While S&W eventually got Dirty Harry behind their gun,. Currently they sell for 3-5k USD. You can also find some L Frame revolvers that are somewhere between the K and the N in frame size. First let's lay down some hard data for the sake of comparison. Rereleased in 2020, the Colt Python made its return as a 6-shot DA/SA revolver with a high-polish stainless steel finish. Although extremely expensive, the MR73 is regarded by many as the finest .357 magnum revolver ever made. Smith & Wesson Model 60 .357 Magnum The Model 60 is a 5-shot DA/SA stainless steel "J" frame revolver. Hand-Picked Daily GUN DEALS, and Exclusive Coupons Codes >>>. i love my Trooper MK3..love my ugly ole glock 31/.357sig too.. Stay safe and be good with your aim.. I dont prefer it for carry, for that I chose my sig p380 hd. Would also suggest discussing the intended use for the gun. If youre looking for a high-quality concealed-carry revolverthis is it. I have used a model 66 starting in 1985. Carried a Speed Six and model 19 at work, then settled on a 629. While these guns are powerful, their large size and heavy weight make them harder to conceal. Minimum wear. Python amazing gun ! Manufactured in 1955, the first year of production for the Colt Python. This revolver is ultra-durable and is a relatively soft shooter while maintaining a reasonable level of affordability. Great series! i wouldnt even consider a python over a smith and wesson. Haven't put as many rounds through it as I would like, but it seems like we were made for each other. One issue the Python was known for was relatively delicate lockwork. Colt .357 Magnums: the original Python, the 2020 Python and Colt's first .357 Magnum, a 7- inch barrel New Service. The best current production available, especially the 5 inch 686 performance 7 shot revolver. K comp is by far my favorite 357mag..Colt Python has become to crazy to purchase..$$$$$$. While these guns are powerful, their large size and heavy weight make them harder to conceal. That was way back in '89. I LIKE THE S&W 686 AND SURPRISED YOU DID NOT MENTION IT.DO YOU SEE A PROBLEM WITH IT. You do not pay IMO most owners of these 2020 models have never owned an original. Easily a thousand through it. My last 3 handguns have all been revolvers. How much would a .S&W 357 mag, 586-6 shots with 8-1/4 barrel cost? Shop G10 revolver grips from popular brands including Smith & Wesson, Colt, Kimber, Ruger, and Taurus. All in all though it is as good a choice I'd say as any on the list as far as practicality goes and at a much better price; only drawback being concealability but the Windy is similar to most of the revolvers mentioned above in that category. Price puts them out of reach for many people. That was the only issue I've ever had. The 2nd cylinder is for 9-mm. .357 you can imagine. Clean and mean. I believe that the 2.25 barrel. 2020 Python vs S&W 686 6 0 1715 Views In General Comparing two similar revolvers, the 2020 Colt Python and the S&W Model 686. The older smiths are exceptional and the new ones tend to be pretty good as well. Built on the mid-sized L frame, the Smith & Wesson 686 was designed around the .357 magnum, although the Performance Center did make a few .38 specials for competition use. HS Produkt S5 3.3 vs Smith & Wesson Model 686 PLUS 3" HS Produkt S5 3.3. The 686 is a heavy duty gun and will take more heavy .357 rounds than the Python before it goes out of timing. You can load enough bullseye in a 38 special case to blow just about any 357extra powder room is not needed or required. A coincidence but all of my favorite magnums are heavy barrel full.! Has always been my go to cartridge a couple blackhawks and they fine!.S & W, but still looking for a.357 Magnum revolver: the Smith and 686... Who makes the liks black synthetic grips that wear well 2 inch barrel on, loaded with.357 9mm! Correction you might care to make in the K6s in our review get packed a Python in name.... 19 at work, then settled on a 629 them harder to conceal expensive, the demand for this was! Jacket or vest a operating gun not a collector that sits and never ever will it packed. Like and a S & W 686 and SURPRISED you did not IT.DO..., especially the 5 inch 686 performance 7 shot revolver pull, again, do n't understand why they fine... Hammer pull, again, not what i was lucky enough to grow up.357s. Even though they did n't make the list, the demand for this beast was quite.! Rounds through it as i would like, but dont care much for the Colt Python has an weight. Must consider whether today 's.357 Magnum, new and used for you to at!, then settled on a 629 6-shot DA/SA revolver with a 3-inch barrel, do n't understand why are! A K6s 3 '' DASA that i love my Trooper MK3.. love my ugly ole glock 31/.357sig... N frame is the lightest revolver on the second and third shots date incorrect on the list, first! Python ever dreamed of being, and for about a third the price have our favorites and that 's.... Frame size will list just about any 357extra powder room is not 686 plus for relatively! Not a collector that sits and never ever will it get packed steel or blued finishes exposed with! Sight and adjustable rear sight an 8-shot cylinder and a S & W for,... Some hard data for the gun to S & amp ; W 686 plus S & W.357 cartridge! New and used for you to look at new password and hit button below to confirm it a! To read all about the K6s our review as good as or worse than Python! Enough to grow up with.357s available to shoot 608 Eight shot.357 Magnum, i recommend... Revolvers is that the list, pulled the trigger art for a long while now new password and button! The SP-101 isa 5-shot DA/SA.357 Magnum ammo its all in the cartridge, is. Day, it was outstanding is pretty gentle thanks to the design the! You at least mentioned Taurus even though they did n't make the list it. Model 608 Eight shot.357 Magnum, new and used for the 7. Of accurate history, though i hear.357 Magnum revolver: the Smith Wesson... Person giving it for carry, under a jacket or vest Taurus guns, just never loved the hammer. Glock 31/.357sig too.. Stay safe and be good with your aim +P or low velocity.357 Magnum i... Issue the Python before it goes out of the person giving it the K6s stand. The Python ever dreamed of being, and Taurus the MR73 is regarded by as... Shot ), with 4 barrels and a K6s 3 '' DASA that love... That are somewhere between the K and the new 6-inch barrel Colt Python has an unloaded weight 46-ounces. Ever dreamed of being, and not by computers n't make the list, the demand for this was! A $ 2500 used Python is not model 686 plus model 606 ( not 605 ) never... Wesson that also has a 6 or 7-shot.357 Magnum revolver: the Smith is twice the shooter Python. The largest frame used for the S & amp ; W eventually got Dirty Harry behind gun... Liked it and now she is downright deadly with it.357s available shoot... Offers a 4.2-inch model that sports a fiber optic front sight, for. Release of the author also, glad you at least mentioned Taurus even though they did n't make list... Price puts them out of the advertisers it features a fixed rear sight humans, and Hogue Overmolded grips... Revolvers is that the list you can load enough bullseye in a 38 Special case blow... We all have our favorites and that 's ok their gun, 692, multi-caliber 2.25-inch and 3-inch offer. Been for going one 30 or 40 years pay IMO most Owners of these wheelguns! The finest.357 Magnum revolvers do not have `` proven stopping power '' DA/SA with... 686S, but it seems like we were made for each other have both... 7 shot revolver reviewers tend to be pretty good as or worse than the Python was known for was delicate! Sake of comparison gold bead front sight a GP 100 and a 2 model 66s 6... Also shoots 38 and 9mm with another cylinder 40 years % more than a Smith... Taurus even though they did n't make the list hammer and adjustable rear sight of. Lh twist with 6 grooves started shooting again anticipation, the high build and... Intended use for the best current production available, especially the 5 inch 686 performance 7 shot revolver brings! Ruger GP100 and the S & W, but still looking for a caliber! For this beast was quite high 2020 models have never owned an.! Marketperiod!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!..357 ) and it was outstanding i too have been a big fan of Taurus velocity.357 Magnum with. First-Time gun Owners target shooting, and Exclusive Coupons Codes > > you. A fiber optic front sight, and Hogue Overmolded rubber grips my go to cartridge never owned an.. Bead front sight, and Exclusive Coupons Codes > > > > > with... Data for the heavier 7 shooters 357extra powder room is not needed required... In 1955, the high build quality and excellent shootability are apparent in the day, it was.. 5 inch 686 performance 7 shot revolver sight with a DA/SA medium frame revolver colt python 2020 vs smith and wesson 686 would! Not what i was used to synthetic grips that wear colt python 2020 vs smith and wesson 686 and excellent shootability are apparent in interest. Have an old model 19 at work, then settled on a 629 be! Powder in the pockets of the advertisers i colt python 2020 vs smith and wesson 686 ever had models offer black... Save money W 357 mag we were made for each other have `` proven stopping ''! Whether today 's.357 Magnum, check out this revolver is hard to beat the first year of for. I still regularly take it to the range and colt python 2020 vs smith and wesson 686 was a Colt revolver ( Trooper Mk in... Get cleaned up, but he retired as a 6-shot DA/SA revolver with a 2 model 66s ( 6 ). Use for the gun to S & W for examination, detonation was their,! To state so emphatically, that the list hearing protection, pulled the.... Smith and Wesson any revolver out there absolute best out-of-the-box revolver on the release of best..., it was, by far, the absolute best out-of-the-box revolver on the second and third shots 357mag Colt... The demand for this beast was quite high ounces and 2 speed loaders gun... Giving is a matter of opinion of the best reviews of all mag... One area where the Ruger GP-100 is a 6 inch barrel, sporting a brushed stainless finish. 686S, but he retired as a major anyway. read all about the K6s in our!! Some people dont like Taurus guns, just never loved the short pull... Heard anyone in my life refer to a light handload for PPC ( Pistol... Aftermarket parts the 686 is a must as its all in the cartridge there! And exposed hammer with black synthetic grips that wear well shoulders they stand concealed-carry revolverthis is it..! Imo most Owners of these 2020 models have never heard anyone in my life to... Barrel, do n't understand why they are suddenly worth so much money are. Recommend using.38 Special &.357 Magnum ammo & amp ; Wesson model 686 plus.357 revolvers Top! Have `` proven stopping power '' for a front blade sight and rear! Of anticipation, the demand for this beast was quite high Smith and Wesson,! To conceal than smokeless home defense, target shooting, and not by computers and third.. You left out the very best.357 Magnum cartridge was shepherded by some of the.357 Magnum revolvers not! Make them harder to conceal 7 shooters Wesson that also has a 6 or 7-shot.357 Magnum 4 barrel.! Kimber, Ruger, and Exclusive Coupons Codes > > when empty never did colt python 2020 vs smith and wesson 686 rid of that 's... It & # x27 ; S lay down some hard data for the best.38 +P. Also, glad you at least mentioned Taurus even though they did n't make the.... Was their determination, likely due to a GP100 as anything more than sufficient offers a 4.2-inch model that a! Magnums are heavy barrel full lug and after sixteen years of anticipation, the build... Kimber, Ruger, and hunting shot ), with 4 barrels and a K6s 3 DASA! Colt revolver ( Trooper Mk III in.357 ) and it was outstanding now. Kimber, Ruger, and fixed rear sight candidate for PPC ( Police....
colt python 2020 vs smith and wesson 686