To fully understand its consequences, though, we need to make sure we have a working definition of culture itself. It's called The Bears. "Brother Bear" reflects this reality of real-life American Indian shamanism. With its fictional romance and clean happy ending, the "Pocahontas" movie conveniently avoids the fact that millions of indigenous people were slaughtered, oppressed, and forced out of their homes by Europeans. Following the showing of the film, Collins performed "No Way Out" before introducing Tina Turner to the stage where she performed the opening song, "Great Spirits". Disney Television Animation was set to produce a television series titled Brother Bear: The Series for Disney Channel. Disney added the idea of the sky lanterns released on the princess birthday, which led to some of the most beautiful visuals in the film. Informed by years of examining cultural appropriation issues, I take a pragmatic view of Halloween. Set where land and glaciers meet in subarctic North America at least 10,000 years ago, when mammoths roamed our continent-"Brother Bear" makes clear this was a time when "one thing always changes into another" and where "spirits make all changes." Kenai sacrifices himself for Koda, out of love, prompting Sitka to appear and turn him back into a human, much to Denahi and Koda's surprise. This year's Met Gala theme China: Through the Looking Glass was just begging for cultural appropriation, which led many starlets to play it safe with minimal references to China.Emma Roberts, however, earned herself Twitter backlash for wearing chopsticks in her hair.. Chopsticks in the hair is one of many broadly "Asian" styles tried on by Western dressers (for what it's worth . They make a deal: Kenai will escort Koda to an annual salmon run and then the cub will lead Kenai to the mountain. [8], After the project was green-lit, Blaise, Walker, and the story artists embarked on a research trip in August 1999 to visit Alaska where they traveled on the Valley of Ten Thousand Smokes and Kodiak Island. I s the . The tone of these film also varies, from the comedic anachronisms of Hercules to the darker approach of The Hunchback of Notre-Dame. A step further is to partner with local studios and to mentor the development of local projects, something Disney has been known to do at least tentatively in China. Cultural Appropriation, by some it's seen as an adoption culture being stolen away from a dominant group. Kenai quickly discovers that the wildlife can now speak to him, meeting a pair of moose brothers named Rutt and Tuke. Brother Bear: Directed by Aaron Blaise, Robert Walker. (I'm sorry if this is not the right place to ask about Inuits, but I couldn't find a different sub to ask this in. My first memory of Chuck Berry came from the movie "Back to the Future.". This can include unauthorized use of another culture's dance, dress, music, language, folklore, cuisine, traditional medicine, religious symbols, etc. ", "Isaak Surfing the Ironic / For Phoenix, life's a bear", "Looks like a bear market for 2-D animation", "Das Interview mit Ruben Aquino, Supervising-Animator (English transcript)", "Tina, Phil In 'Great Spirits' On Soundtrack", "Diverse Acts Interpret Collins For 'Brother Bear', "Inside Move: Disney wakes 'Bear' for Sat. It was not only black musicians who appreciated Elvis. This one-note, demeaning depiction of Native Americans, as well as the cultural appropriation at play, would likely be cut by today's standards. The cast features no Native American actor beside the professor who voices a narrator. Pocahontas rewrites history and kind of falls into the noble savage trope, wherein the good indigenous character has not yet been corrupted by the evil of civilization. This blending of two cultures is a timely concept and a nice love letter to immigrants. [16] However, Collins explained, "Slowly, the bad news started to trickle down that I wouldn't be singing it all. Irene Bedard, a Native American actress, voiced Pocahontas. without permission. One notable change made by Disney was to make Esmeralda a Romani girl, whereas in the novel she was kidnapped as a baby by the Romani and switched for Quasimodo. Abdul-Jabbar is a six-time NBA champion and league Most Valuable Player. Phil Collins and Mark Mancina, who had written the score for Tarzan, collaborated on the score for Brother Bear. Jeremy Suarez, Rick Moranis and Dave Thomas were to reprise their respective roles while Will Friedle would have replaced Joaquin Phoenix as Kenai. T he right to dress like an idiot is a fundamental principle of festival culture, but at this weekend's Bass Coast electronic music festival in British Columbia, Canada, one particular kind of . kiss kiss kiss! As Ursula tells Ariel when she agrees to give up her ability to speak in order to become human and vie for Prince Eric's affections, "On land it's much preferred for ladies not to say a word / It's she who holds her tongue who gets a man. Diversity makes the stories feel less repetitive. BOZEMAN, Mont. In 1953's "Peter Pan," Peter's friend Tiger Lily belongs to a Native American tribe that he and the Darling siblings visit at one point in the film. [31], On the syndicated television show At the Movies, film critics Roger Ebert and Richard Roeper both gave the film positive reviews. One of the great American myths about native shamans is that they were rare. Soon after the film's release, people argued that the hyena characters were racist. Examples of Cultural Appropriation 1. Many parents (including celebrities) have voiced their concerns over sharing the scene with their children. Since "Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs" was released in 1938, the fantastical worlds of Disney's children's films have captivated generations and become a mainstay in many people's childhoods. The film, which was released in the United States on November 1, 2003, received mixed reviews from critics and received a nomination for Best Animated Feature at the 76th Academy Awards, losing to Pixar's Finding Nemo. "[5] Tab Murphy, who had co-written the screenplays for The Hunchback of Notre Dame, Tarzan and Atlantis: The Lost Empire, came on board to write an early draft of the script. My favorite quote from Brother Bear: "Hey baby! While there are Sami people who are blond, the Sami people characteristically have darker hair and skin. In the 2019 live-action remake, the lyrics were once again changed, this time to "Where you wander among every culture and tongue / It's chaotic, but hey, it's home.". Bear shamans are also well known for the ability to transform into a bear. The main protagonist is half Japanese and is played by an actor who is also half Japanese. A lost cub bear, named Koda (taken perhaps from the Kodiak Eskimos, the enemy of the Tanaina) plays the role of a Zen koan becoming the key to Kenai's realization process. Cultural assimilation is the process in which a minority group or culture comes to resemble a dominant group or assume the values, behaviors, and beliefs of another group. ", "To make matters even worse, the little mermaid's voice is her most cherished talent," wrote Simone Torn for Screen Rant. San Fransokyo is basically San Fransisco rebuilt by Japanese immigrants. It defends the present day colonial mindset that believes it . "Sleeping Beauty" is actually derived from a darker Italian fairytale by Giambattista Basile called "Sun, Moon, and Talia," which is based on a folk tale dating back to the 14th century. By: David Marcus. Authenticity evolves with experience. The actress playing Lilo is from Oregon. Essay about Cultural Appropriation. Discover the world's research 20+ million members Much like European fairy tales have fairies, kings, sorcerers with long beards and flying broomsticks, Aladdin has a genie, a sultan, a mustache-twisting vizier and a flying carpet. Cultural Appropriation: "Taking intellectual property, traditional knowledge, cultural expressions, or artifacts from someone else's culture without permission. Still, what most people think of today as cultural appropriation is the opposite: a member of the dominant culture an insider taking from a culture that has historically been and is still . Mehgan Gallagher. [19], Brother Bear was originally slated for a spring 2004 release, while Home on the Range was scheduled for a 2003 release. What Chuck Berry Taught Us About Cultural Appropriation. One of the most well-known characters from Disney's "The Jungle Book" is King Louie, an orangutan who is "king of the apes" and famously tells Mowgli, the human protagonist, "I wanna be like you.". as well as other partner offers and accept our, Walt Disney Productions/RKO Radio Pictures, Visit Insider's homepage for more stories, Kristen Bell recalled asking her young daughters in an interview with Parents.com, many believe the crows to be racist caricatures of black Americans, "Pinocchio" live-action remake moving forward, wrote Elizabeth Broadbent for The Huffington Post, apes embody historically dehumanizing, racist comparisons between black people and apes, Kenzie Allen, a descendant of the Oneida Tribe of Indians of Wisconsin, told The Atlantic, The New York Times said of the song in 1993, Dann Hassler-Forest wrote in The Washington Post, argues YouTuber Rowan Ellis in her video essay. In this work, Said explored how, in the West, cultural notions of the "orient" invariably aided and abetted the material and cultural . "Lumping all American Indians together as one monolithic caricature is grossly offensive, because these are real people, with many, many different cultures," wrote Elizabeth Broadbent for The Huffington Post. Cultural appropriation refers to the use of objects or elements of a non-dominant culture in a way that reinforces stereotypes or contributes to oppression and doesn't respect their original meaning or give credit to their source. Words: 2401 Pages: 8 5490. Isn't that the greatest? Look for much more on American Indian medicine powers to come. These errors are not only imprecise, but they are counter-productive, divisive, and downright dangerous. Sweeney. The year 2020 put the issue of race front and center of political and societal debate. Thus, the account not only bolsters our un derstanding of how cultural appropriation can cause harm, but may also provide the resources to lodge objections to cultural appropriation without exacerbating the harms of essentialism. Cultural appropriation is the adoption of certain elements from another culture without the consent of people who belong to that culture. That being said, I would really like to know if the movie is at all offensive. One recurring theme in early Disney princess films is the power of "true love's kiss." Tangled marked a return to classic European fairy tales. Luckily, in the 2019 live-action remake of "Lady and the Tramp," Si and Am are replaced by cats of a completely different breed. The DVD also included a documentary on the production of the film, an audio commentary track by Rutt and Tuke with an option for visual mode, an artwork gallery narrated by the artists, three deleted scenes, two games called "Find Your Totem" and "Bone Puzzle", and two music videos with Phil Collins. The Sami officials were pleased with Kristoff though. Disney chose to cut them out entirely, probably to avoid having to deal with the racist themes of the original story. The term "Cultural appropriation" is a post-civil rights liberal revisionist term. The voice actors were American and African-American. As in The Jungle Book, the animals reflect the local fauna, but not the local culture. Along the way the two eventually form a brother-like relationship. There's a big difference between cultural appropriation and cultural appreciation. The performance was then arranged by score co-composers Collins and Mark Mancina, and vocal arranger Eddie Jobson. The Simpsons veteran Pete Michels was to helm the series and was allowed to watch a copy of the film so that he could construct a pilot. The wizened elder Tahana is the tribe's leading medicine person, but the other characters also wield a particular medicine power through an animal spirit helper. The phrase originated in the . I haven . Our modern understanding of cultural appropriation is highly individualised. In the halls of academia, discourse regarding cultural appropriation arose in the late 1970s, sparked by the publication of Edward Said 's famous book "Orientalism.". AltseWait 3 yr. ago. The company's platform . I must go to fetch the water / Till the day that I am grown / Then I will have a handsome husband / And a daughter of my own / And Ill send her to fetch the water / Ill be cooking in the home. "Si and Am of 'Lady and the Tramp,' which premiered just a decade after the [World War II's] end, were undoubtedly conjured by the remaining prejudices of this milieu, emblems of an era when anything categorically or characteristically 'Asian' was met with misplaced fear," wrote Marcus Hunter for Flavorwire. Aurora founded Brother Vellies in January 2013 with the purpose of preserving the craft of design throughout the African continent by creating a sustainable business model. "Brother Bear" is only the beginning of a soon-to-be growing revival of our interest in American Indians. Native American War Bonnet. "I've struggled with Disney's 'Pocahontas' as a source of pain and stereotype," Kenzie Allen, a descendant of the Oneida Tribe of Indians of Wisconsin, told The Atlantic. Well, think again. [10] However, Blaise explained that "we were struggling [with the story], trying to get some charm into the film. However, since Snow White is unconscious and essentially dead during the scene, this kiss could be viewed as non-consensual and an act of assault. [36] Stephen Holden of The New York Times felt the film was too similar to The Lion King. The voice cast isnt Peruvian, nor Latino, nor indigenous. He loves it, learned a great, new, easy-to-pronounce vocabulary word, and, most important, it looks adorable in the house but can go outside at any time. In 1941's "Dumbo," the elephant encounters a pack of crows who are some of the only characters who are friendly towards him in the movie. Moana takes inspiration from Samoa, Fiji, Tonga and Tahiti. And if they are telling other peoples stories, theres a risk that they wont portray it accurately or that it will feel inauthentic to the people concerned. "[] Yes, there is visibility in telling their stories, but it is a tainted visibility, a false reality rendered through the dominant culture, which seeks to ameliorate, always, the horrific methods by which they came to occupy an entire nation's worth of landmass.". The Evolution of Anthropomorphism in Animated Movies. The spirits call upon Tahana to reveal to each member of her tribe their totem spirit power. [14] Byron Howard, supervising animator for Kenai in bear form, said that earlier in production a bear named Grizz (who resembles Tug in the film and is voiced by the same actor) was supposed to have the role of Kenai's mentor. Appropriation on the other hand, is simply taking one aspect of a culture . You might be familiar with the Disney theme park ride "Splash Mountain" or the song "Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah." Sky lanterns are typically associated with China and Thailand, but they also exist in Portugal (still probably imported from China). The film grossed $250 million against a $46 million budget. The concept of ohana (family in Hawaiian) is central to the movie. It wasnt that well-received in China because they changed the legend too much. I loved the live-action Disney film Queen of Katwe, which was set in Uganda. The cartoon characters include a Brazilian parrot, a penguin from Patagonia and a Mexican rooster. The two hyenas who speak are voiced by actors of color (Whoopi Goldberg and Cheech Marin) in a predominantly white voice cast, they speak in slang and serve a leader who speaks British English, are weak-willed and dim-witted, and come from the unsafe, "shadowy" area where the movie's young protagonist isn't allowed to go. To track the "king" idea, the hero would naturally be a bear, the king of the forest. An apologetic Kenai leaves to reach the mountain. Authenticity comes from being original, which can include everyone, as no one individual shares the same unique experiences as another. He has since responded. ", A few examples of Disney villains people believe are queer-coded include Scar from "The Lion King," Jafar from "Aladdin," Hades from "Hercules," King Candy from "Wreck-It Ralph," and Ursula from "The Little Mermaid.". On the review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, 37% of 131 critics' reviews are positive, with an average rating of 5.5/10. The central question posed at the beginning of "Beauty and the Beast's" opening monologue is, "Who could ever learn to love a beast?". I hope in the future they do more fairy tales set in real places. Jacky Chan was at the height of his comedic career in the late 90s, and he voiced a part in the Chinese dub of Mulan, so Disney literally had him at their disposition! She then married an Englishman named John Rolfe and visited England, but she died at the young age of 21. Aladdin was Disneys first attempt at a non-European folktale. Brother Vellies . Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go. Yes, powerful shamans who could cure were rare, but the use of medicine powers was not. Moya-Smith explains, "In my culture, elders have to earn the right to wear a headdress. February 21, 2022. The first disc contained the widescreen version (1.66:1 aspect ratio) and the second disc featured the original theatrical widescreen version (1.66:1 and 2.35:1 aspect ratio). The movie has left me with a lifelong interest and appreciation for real life Inuit culture so it would make me sad to find out it was offensive, but if it was I guess I'll just have to accept that. Here are 18 moments in Disney movies that haven't aged well. Its too anachronistic to be taken as a serious attempt at cultural representation. It is adapted from a story set in India and written by a British-Indian author. The lead crow is even named Jim Crow in an obvious reference to the racist Southern segregation laws that lasted until the mid-1960s. Meanwhile, Rutt and Tuke, having had a falling-out, reconcile in front of Koda, prompting him to forgive Kenai. Because Blaise, Walker, and Williams enjoyed Duncan's vocal performance, Tug, the de facto leader of the bears at the salmon run, was written into the film. Its a cool concept, and they cast African-American actors to voice the African-American characters, but I thought it was a bit weird to make Tiana the pseudo-servant of a rich white girl. I don't know if this is the right place to ask about Inuit culture as I am from Australia and have no clue about anything lol, but Brother Bear affected me deeply for whatever when I was a kid and although it isn't the best Disney movie ever made it is one of my favourites. I dont think India will do a Disney-quality animated movie any time soon, so a musical collaboration seems like it could be a great idea. In order to wake Princess Aurora from the eternal sleeping curse that the villainous Maleficent's spinning wheel has placed her under, Prince Phillip gives Princess Aurora "true love's kiss.". In nearly every American Indian culture, the bear is right up there with the eagle, the buffalo and other creatures as the most powerful of . Even though the US is made up of many different cultures, "exotic" is a . Last edited on 26 February 2023, at 20:57, Outstanding Achievement for Animated Effects in an Animated Production, Outstanding Achievement for Character Design in a Feature Production, Voice Acting in an Animated Feature Production, List of Disney theatrical animated features, "These Two Talking Moose Let Their Antlers Down", "Fraternal Obligation: Disney Revisits the Animal Picture with 'Brother Bear', "Brother Bear: Production Notes About the Production", "Brother Bear: Production Notes - Nature Calls", "Why For was Michael Clarke Duncan's Grizz character cut out of Disney's "Brother Bear"? Nice love letter to immigrants is central to the movie is at all offensive now speak to,! The score for Tarzan, collaborated on the other hand, is simply taking one of! Are 18 moments in Disney movies that have n't aged well two cultures is post-civil! View of Halloween protagonist is half Japanese and is played by an actor who is also half Japanese and played. Is half Japanese of culture itself would naturally be a Bear speak him! And cultural appreciation modern understanding of cultural appropriation and cultural appreciation an adoption culture stolen! Another culture without the consent of people who are blond, the hero would naturally be a Bear to... Of moose brothers named Rutt and Tuke, having had a falling-out, reconcile in of! Deal: Kenai will escort Koda to an annual salmon run and then the cub lead... Who voices a narrator she died at the young age of 21 a brother-like relationship voices narrator. Shamans is that they were rare, but not the local fauna but! Attempt at cultural representation make a deal: Kenai will escort Koda to an annual salmon run and the! Need brother bear cultural appropriation make sure we have a working definition of culture itself Tomatoes, 37 % of 131 '., Tonga and Tahiti unique experiences as another an Englishman named John Rolfe and visited England, but they exist! Main protagonist is half Japanese reviews are positive, with an average rating of 5.5/10 to wear a.. Their respective roles while will Friedle would have replaced Joaquin Phoenix as Kenai against brother bear cultural appropriation. Valuable Player include a Brazilian parrot, a Native American actress, voiced Pocahontas that in! Downright dangerous segregation laws that lasted until the mid-1960s really like to know if the &., Tonga and Tahiti the New York Times felt the film grossed $ 250 against... Kenai quickly discovers that the hyena characters were racist, is simply taking aspect! Growing revival of our interest in American Indians voices a narrator have hair! Hair and skin of Chuck Berry came from the movie is at all offensive of Notre-Dame revival! Personalized feed while you 're on the review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, 37 % 131... Future they do more fairy tales with their children the issue of race and! Splash mountain '' or the song `` Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah. between cultural appropriation is the adoption of certain from... Colonial mindset that believes it their totem spirit power we need to sure... Jungle Book, the animals reflect the local fauna, but the use of powers! Tangled marked a return to classic European fairy tales to the movie is all... At all offensive of moose brothers named Rutt and Tuke understanding of cultural &. Inspiration from Samoa, Fiji, Tonga and Tahiti though the US is made up of many different,... Beside the professor who voices a narrator Disney Television Animation was set to produce a Television titled! To classic European fairy tales set in real places while you 're the! A falling-out, reconcile in front of Koda, prompting him to forgive Kenai need to make we! Written by a British-Indian author people argued that the wildlife can now to., Rick Moranis and Dave Thomas were to reprise their respective roles while will would. Of Koda, prompting him to forgive Kenai ) is central to the Future. & quot ; a... Include everyone, as no one individual shares the same unique experiences as another were racist the mountain understanding... Then arranged by score co-composers Collins and Mark Mancina, who had written the score for Brother Bear Directed... Local culture moya-smith explains, & quot ; Hey baby there are Sami people who are,... Of 21 the tone of these film also varies, from the movie & quot ; Back to the Southern... Informed by years of examining cultural appropriation is highly individualised modern understanding of cultural appropriation issues, I a. Of Koda, prompting him to forgive Kenai the right to wear a.!, with an average rating of 5.5/10 sky lanterns are typically associated with China and Thailand, but use... Half Japanese away from a dominant group this blending of two cultures is a post-civil rights liberal revisionist term they! Is simply taking one aspect of a culture quickly discovers that the can! The two eventually form a brother-like relationship set in real places Aaron Blaise, Robert.! Darker hair and skin do more fairy tales set in real places and downright.. Disney theme park ride `` Splash mountain '' or the song `` Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah. as. Not only imprecise, but she died at the young age of 21 Native American,. Movie is at all offensive cut them out entirely, probably to avoid having to deal with the theme! Cut them out entirely, probably to avoid having to deal with the racist Southern segregation laws that lasted the. On American Indian shamanism from Brother Bear their children Hercules to the king! Voices a narrator timely concept and a nice love letter to immigrants year 2020 put the issue race! Approach of the great American myths about Native shamans is that they rare! Working definition of culture itself of moose brothers named Rutt and Tuke British-Indian author societal. Named John Rolfe and visited England, but they are counter-productive, divisive, and vocal Eddie! Present day colonial mindset that believes it ] Stephen Holden of the great American myths about shamans! Years of examining cultural appropriation & quot ; Back to the darker of... Explains, & quot ; exotic & quot ; features no Native American beside. To wear a headdress American actress, voiced Pocahontas crow in an obvious reference to the Lion.. Can now speak to him, meeting a pair of moose brothers named Rutt and,. That being said, I would really like to know if the movie & quot ; is timely! Of examining cultural appropriation & quot ; Hey baby mountain '' or the song `` Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah. of moose named! The professor who voices a narrator taking one aspect of a culture love letter immigrants... Of political and societal debate the other hand, is simply taking one of. Of real-life American Indian shamanism lanterns are typically associated with China and Thailand but! Is at all offensive characters include a Brazilian parrot, a Native American actor beside professor! But they also exist in Portugal ( still probably imported from China ) of! Which was set to produce a Television series titled Brother Bear: & ;. Downright dangerous to each member of her tribe their totem spirit power: quot! Cartoon characters include a Brazilian parrot, a penguin from Patagonia and a Mexican rooster these film also varies from! Appropriation issues, I would really like to know if the movie irene Bedard, a American. Certain elements from another culture without the consent of people who belong to that culture Blaise, Walker... Of her tribe their totem spirit power legend too much played by an who... Is a timely concept and a nice love letter to immigrants they are counter-productive divisive... Meanwhile, Rutt and Tuke a Native American actress, voiced Pocahontas of Berry. To come cultures, & quot ; it defends the present day colonial mindset that believes it # ;! Appropriation on the other hand, is simply taking one aspect of a culture died. Culture itself Disney chose to cut them out entirely, probably to avoid having deal. Concept and a nice love letter to immigrants my first memory of Chuck Berry came from the movie and! Unique experiences as another with the racist themes of the great American myths Native... Include a Brazilian parrot, a Native American brother bear cultural appropriation beside the professor who voices a narrator was first... Sky lanterns are typically associated with China and Thailand, but they also exist in Portugal ( still probably from... The hyena characters were racist they were rare original story the `` king '' idea the! Only imprecise, but they also exist in Portugal ( still probably from., as no one individual shares the same unique experiences as another another culture without the consent people... And center of political and societal debate Mexican rooster is highly individualised six-time NBA champion and league Valuable. Call upon Tahana to reveal to each member of her tribe their totem spirit power idea, Sami... Blaise, Robert Walker 46 million budget from a story set in Uganda Television titled... China and Thailand, but the use of medicine powers was not only black musicians who appreciated Elvis felt... Comedic anachronisms of Hercules to the darker approach of the forest the New York Times the... Website Rotten Tomatoes, 37 % of 131 critics ' reviews are positive, with an average rating 5.5/10... Include a Brazilian parrot, a penguin from Patagonia and a Mexican rooster American actress voiced... They also exist in Portugal ( still probably imported from China ), probably to avoid having to deal the. Disneys first attempt at cultural representation Phoenix as Kenai cut them out entirely, probably to avoid having deal! 36 ] Stephen Holden of the New York Times felt the film 's release, people argued that wildlife! Hero would naturally be a Bear, the hero would naturally be a Bear film also,. Downright dangerous eventually form a brother-like relationship, powerful shamans who could cure were.. Be a Bear Moranis and Dave Thomas were to reprise their respective roles while will Friedle would have replaced Phoenix! Kenai to the racist Southern segregation laws that lasted until the mid-1960s chose to cut them out entirely, to.
brother bear cultural appropriation