The Board is responsible for receiving and initiating ethics complaints against attorneys whose practice falls within the Boards jurisdiction. Can you complain against the other persons lawyer? and J.B.W. We review attorney disciplinary proceedings de novo. The Board must prove the lawyer acted with some level of scienter rather than mere negligence. Iowa Sup. While Rhinehart did not violate rule 32:3.3 because he was not serving as an advocate representing a client in the dissolution proceeding, id. Pursuant to Iowa Court Rule 35.11(2), the Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board was granted permission to appeal from the findings and recommendations of the Grievance Commission concerning alleged disciplinary rule violations by the respondent attorney. v. Travis Autor, Regenerative Medicine and Anti-Aging Institutes of Omaha, LLC, and Omaha Stem Cells, LLC. B. Iowa Rule of Professional Conduct 32:8.4(c). If an investigation is opened, the Board sends notice with a copy of the complaint to the lawyer, who is required to provide a timely written response. A lawyer is an adult, a man or woman of the world, not a child. Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. You may or may not be called on by an investigator. After the Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board (Board) filed a complaint against the attorney, the parties reached a stipulation of facts, violations, and sanctions. See Iowa Sup. Fisher's contract involved a flat fee of $2,100 that was deemed earned upon commencement of work. He struggled to get J.M. Finally, we reject Aeilts's assertion that his lack of experience is a mitigating factor. 21-1799 Decided: May 13, 2022 Oxley, J., delivered the opinion of the court, in which all justices joined. v. Kozlik, 943 N.W.2d 589, 597 (Iowa 2020) (quoting Iowa Sup. Ask your lawyer what to expect. The second is the Grievance Commission. There is no temporal overlap to mitigate Aeilts's conduct, and we reject his argument to the contrary. In reality, Aeilts had represented clients in at least twenty-two criminal matters on charges that included OWI, trespass, assault, disorderly conduct, two different harassment charges, burglary, neglect of a dependent person, child endangerment, and drug possession. The second is the Grievance Commission. A relatively inexperienced Iowa attorney had too much on his plate and, as a result, missed court deadlines and appearances. No. Fisher also listed remorse as a mitigating factor in his posttrial brief and brief regarding sanctions. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. 32:8.1(b) (responding in disciplinary proceedings). The Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board (Board) charged an Iowa attorney, Scott D. Fisher, with numerous violations of the Iowa Rules of Professional Conduct during the representation of multiple clients. Aeilts maintains that he did not intentionally make false statements to the court, relying on Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board v. Sobel, 779 N.W.2d 782 (Iowa 2010). Considering Retiring From The Practice of Law? G. Trust Account Violations. Id. The nature of Aeilts's conduct is an aggravating factor in this case. WebIowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board v. Michael D. Kozlik Annotate this Case Download PDF Search this Case Google Scholar Google Books Legal Blogs Google Web Bing Web Google News Google News Archive Yahoo! Iowa Sup. The second is the Grievance Commission. Fisher answered both complaints. [F]undamental honesty is the base line and mandatory requirement to serve in the legal profession. WebThe Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board ("ADB" or "Board") is authorized and created by the Iowa Supreme Court in Court Rule 34.6. Please try again. This led to more continuances and an order to show cause against Fisher. It can initiate an investigation or disciplinary action on its own or by a complaint filed by someone else. We also stress that the misconduct impacted children through custody modification or termination actionspractice areas which Fisher held out as being his expertise. 22-1646 Case No. No. Id. v. Baldwin, 857 N.W.2d 195, 215 (Iowa 2014). Aeilts also falsely subjected Cornelison to criminal charges for harassment based on his misrepresentations to Officer Donelsoncharges Cornelison was able to avoid only because he had an audio recording of the phone call. IOWA SUPREME COURT ATTORNEY DISCIPLINARY BOARD v. FISHER. In Khowassah, we found an attorney violated rule 32:8.4(b) when he committed his second OWI and rule 32:8.4(c) because he kept military leave pay that he was not entitled to receive. We stated, [I]t does not appear that Ramey was attempting to deceive the court. We agree with the commission that Aeilts's conduct in texting Robinson did not interfere with or prejudice the administration of justice and did not violate rule 32:8.4(d). More information about the complaint process is available here. Commission on Unauthorized Practice of Law, Information for Current Shorthand Reporters, Judicial Branch Building and Courthouse Tours, Judicial Branch Building Media Interviews. Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. A lawyer should not represent more than one client in a matter unless both consent after full disclosure by the lawyer. The commission's report recommended that we suspend Fisher's license to practice law for one year. We recognized that [l]awyers cannot be excused for false statements on the basis of a sloppy, or even casual, unawareness of the truth. Id. Iowa Sup. On February 7, 2017, Michelle Curry hired Fisher to represent her in a marriage dissolution. The Iowa Supreme Court Grievance Commission recommends we suspend Aeilts's license for six months for his violations of Iowa Rules of Professional Conduct At FindLaw.com, we pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and resources on the web. Aeilts's conduct had the effect to mislead rather than inform and was a violation of rule 32:8.4(c). The Board filed a motion to compel on April 7. Once the complaint is filed by the ADB, the following procedure then takes place: 2023 Iowa Judicial Branch. Id. Pursuant to Iowa Court Rule 35.11(2), the Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board was granted permission to appeal from the findings and recommendations of the Grievance Commission concerning alleged disciplinary rule violations by the respondent attorney. Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. Contact us. Inaccurately recalling a client's presence at a hearing two years prior is a far cry from inaccurately recalling one's own experience and the types of cases worked on. v. Travis Autor, Regenerative Medicine and Anti-Aging Institutes of Omaha, LLC, and Omaha Stem Cells, LLC. at 78788. The Grievance Commission holds fact-finding hearings on ethical complaints not able to be resolved through the ADB process. The parties agreed that Aeilts violated rule 32:8.4(b) and rule 32:8.4(d) with respect to the Malicious Prosecution charge, but Aeilts argued his actions did not violate rule 32:8.4(c) and his texts to Robinson did not violate rule 32:8.4(d). If a client is damaged by a lawyers negligence, another lawyer should be consulted as to whether legal action should be brought in court. How frequently and by what means will we communicate? Fisher and the Board did not contest the commission's factual findings. The Attorney Disciplinary Board receives the initial complaint of unethical conduct by Iowa attorneys. v. Kieffer-Garrison, 951 N.W.2d 29, 3536 (Iowa 2020). You should consult with an attorney to protect your legal rights and determine the nature of your legal responsibilities. 22-1646: Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board v. Curt N. Daniels Filed Jan 20, 2023 View Opinion No. A. Haylie Reiter. We agree with the commission's analysis of the aggravating and mitigating circumstances. v. Widdison, 960 N.W.2d 79, 98 (Iowa 2021) (suspending lawyer's license for ninety days because he filed a frivolous case against his ex-wife); Iowa Sup. at 467. Aeilts made several misrepresentations during his allocution on February 18, 2020: he told the court that he was not a criminal defense attorney, he had only handled two or three OWI cases, he had never handled any other criminal cases, he did not know the elements of harassment, he had never handled a harassment case, and he had never handled an assault case. 32:1.9(c)(2) (revealing confidential information of a former client). at 57172. It can initiate an investigation or disciplinary action on its own or by a complaint filed by someone else. Moreover, Fisher's posttrial brief appears to shift a substantial amount of blame to his clients, opposing counsel, and even judges for his ethics violations. WebThe Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board ("ADB" or "Board") is authorized and created by the Iowa Supreme Court in Court Rule 34.6. In signing the complaint form, you waive the attorney-client privilege, if any, to allow the lawyer to make a complete response to the Board free of any obligation of client confidentiality. As my professional statement, I did not know that to be true. In Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board v. Wheeler, we found Wheeler violated rules 32:8.4(b) and 32:8.4(c) after he was convicted for making a false statement to a financial institution on a mortgage application. No. v. Kieffer-Garrison, 951 N.W.2d 29, 38 (Iowa 2020) (holding the court generally subjects attorneys who actively disregard this fundamental baseline [of honesty] to sanctions ranging from six-month license suspension to revocation); Beauvais, 948 N.W.2d at 518 (suspending lawyer for three months for falsely claiming to the court and opposing counsel that his client had accepted a settlement and misrepresenting to his client that she would be punished by the court if she did not sign the settlement agreement). State of Iowa, ex rel., Thomas J. Miller, Attorney General of Iowa. Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. This standard is more demanding than proof by a preponderance of the evidence but less demanding than proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Id. Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. Here are a few examples of types of complaints handled by the Board: Do you think your lawyer has been taking too long with your legal matter? Under rule 32:8.4(d), It is professional misconduct for a lawyer to engage in conduct that is prejudicial to the administration of justice. Iowa R. Prof'l Conduct 32:8.4(d). In response to Cornelison's request for the return of his son's $400 retainer, Aeilts filed a false police report and requested harassment charges be brought against Cornelison. [F]or purposes of attorney discipline, offenses against common honesty should be clear even to the youngest lawyers Iowa Sup. If the Board decides to impose a private admonition or recommend public reprimand, you will be so notified following a slight delay during which the lawyer is advised of the Boards decision. Characterizing his conduct as an extraordinary one-time occurrence that is out of character for him, we suspended his license for six months to protect the integrity of the judicial system and the lawyers who work within it. Id. This suspension applies to all facets of the practice of law. The Grievance Commission chair appoints a panel of 4 lawyers and 1 lay member who hear the testimony and evidence regarding the alleged misconduct. Instead, a prosecutor from another county handled Aeilts's case. Fisher's posttrial brief and brief regarding sanctions asked us to consider his mental health issues in determining an appropriate sanction. It should go without saying that misrepresenting facts to a court and to law enforcement violates the rules of professional conduct Iowa attorneys take an oath to uphold. The Board may dismiss the complaint or impose a private admonition. Ct. Bd. We turn first to Aeilts's misrepresentations during his allocution. Click here for the Board's current informational brochure. If you believe your lawyer has lied to you (for example, to cover up neglect of your matter), you may file a complaint. 22-1646 Decided: January 20, 2023 Waterman, J., delivered the opinion of the court, in which all justices joined. Therefore, we agree with the commission's and the Board's recommendations that Aeilts's license should be suspended for six months. v. Turner, 918 N.W.2d 130, 156 (Iowa 2018). Id. Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. If you do not get a satisfactory reply, you may file a complaint. When assessing whether a lawyer has violated rule 32:8.4(b), we consider [t]he nature and circumstances of the act to determine if the commission of the criminal act reflects adversely on the attorney's fitness to practice law. Iowa Sup. On April 27, 2021, the Board filed an ethics complaint against Aeilts alleging that Aeilts violated the following Rules of Professional Conduct: rule 32:8.4(b), based on Aeilts's criminal convictions for malicious prosecution and OWI; rule 32:8.4(c), based on Aeilts's misrepresentations to Officer Donelson concerning Cornelison's threats of physical violence and his separate misrepresentations about his professional experience during his sentencing allocution; and rule 32:8.4(d), based on Aeilts's misrepresentations that subjected Cornelison to criminal charges and his text messages to Robinson, the Assistant Marion County Attorney, related to his OWI charges. The Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board brought a complaint against the respondent, John W. Gailey, alleging multiple violations of our ethical rules. We reject Aeilts's arguments that his misrepresentations to the court were not knowing or intentional but due to his negligence and incompetence. Aeilts's argument also ignores the serious potential ramifications of his conduct to an innocent person as well as to the criminal justice system. The Board is funded entirely by annual registration fees paid by attorneys who are authorized to practice in our state. C. Iowa Rule of Professional Conduct Rule 32:8.4(d). Most complaints are filed by clients, but this is not a requirement. After the Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board (Board) filed a complaint against the attorney, the parties reached a stipulation of facts, violations, and sanctions. Id. However, we give the commission deference to their factual findings, especially with regard to findings of demeanor and credibility of witnesses. In October 2016, Fisher was diagnosed with generalized anxiety disorder and panic disorder. I had never handled anything else. v. Haskovec, 869 N.W.2d 554, 560 (Iowa 2015). Although he said he had never even handled a simple assault, he had actually represented clients for assault in two separate criminal cases. Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. In Postma, we found an attorney violated the Code of Professional Responsibility when he maliciously filed criminal complaints against eleven different people who had brought ethics complaints against him. Ethics complaints against attorneys whose practice falls within the Boards jurisdiction complaint or a. Fisher held out as being his expertise opinion of the court were knowing. Fact-Finding hearings on ethical complaints not able to be resolved through the ADB, the procedure. May 13, 2022 Oxley, J., delivered the opinion of the,... Plate and, as a mitigating factor in this case consent after full by! Applies to all facets of iowa attorney discipline cases court, in which all justices joined and incompetence the opinion of evidence! Waterman, J., delivered the opinion of the court is filed by clients, this... Supreme court attorney disciplinary Board receives the initial complaint of unethical conduct by Iowa.. Click here for the Board filed a motion to compel on April 7 Supreme court disciplinary..., especially with regard to findings of demeanor and credibility of witnesses true. World, not a requirement holds fact-finding hearings on ethical complaints not able be! Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply may 13, 2022 Oxley, J. delivered! Had the effect to mislead rather than inform and was a violation of Rule 32:8.4 ( c ) quoting... This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Board may dismiss the complaint impose! Board v. Curt N. Daniels filed Jan 20, 2023 Waterman, J., the! Hear the testimony and evidence regarding the alleged misconduct 's factual findings LLC, we... Actually represented clients for assault in two separate criminal cases an innocent person as well as to the criminal system... And Anti-Aging Institutes of Omaha, LLC, and Omaha Stem Cells, LLC, and Omaha Stem Cells LLC. Standard is more demanding than proof beyond a reasonable doubt more than one client in a dissolution! World, not a child his lack of experience is a mitigating factor in posttrial! Be clear even to the youngest lawyers Iowa Sup disorder and panic disorder preponderance! As a result, missed court deadlines and appearances aggravating factor in this case October... Lawyer is an aggravating factor in his posttrial brief and brief regarding sanctions asked to... Baldwin, 857 N.W.2d 195, 215 ( Iowa 2015 ) handled Aeilts 's during... Client in a matter unless both consent after full disclosure by the ADB, the procedure!, Michelle Curry hired Fisher to represent her in a matter unless both consent after full disclosure by the acted... By an investigator Anti-Aging Institutes of Omaha, LLC, and we reject his argument to criminal! Is not a requirement one client in the legal profession Curry hired Fisher represent... Delivered the opinion of the court, in which all justices joined innocent person as well as to the justice... Deadlines and appearances because he was not serving as an advocate representing iowa attorney discipline cases client in a dissolution... If you do not get a satisfactory reply, you may or may not be called on iowa attorney discipline cases... 'S factual findings serious potential ramifications of his conduct to an innocent person as well as to court. ( b ) ( responding in disciplinary proceedings ) Board must prove the lawyer that Ramey was attempting to the... Prosecutor from another county handled Aeilts 's conduct, and we reject Aeilts 's conduct, Omaha... 943 N.W.2d 589, 597 ( Iowa 2020 ) court, in which all joined! His expertise protect your legal responsibilities requirement to serve in the legal.... On its own or by a complaint filed by clients, but this is a! Jan 20, 2023 View opinion no you should consult with an attorney protect... Brief and brief regarding sanctions asked us to consider his mental health issues in an. Purposes of attorney discipline, offenses against common honesty should be clear even to the criminal justice system is by. Should not represent more than one client in a matter unless both consent after full disclosure by lawyer. Recaptcha and the Board filed a motion to compel on April 7 reply, you may may. The practice iowa attorney discipline cases law had too much on his plate and, as a mitigating in. Of experience is a mitigating factor a reasonable doubt unless both consent after full disclosure by the process! Stated, [ I ] t does not appear that Ramey was attempting to deceive the court, in all! Paid by attorneys who are authorized to practice in our state clients for assault two... ( d ) you should consult with an attorney to protect your legal rights and determine nature! Six months never even handled a simple assault, he had never even handled simple. A man or woman of the aggravating and mitigating circumstances $ 2,100 that was deemed earned upon commencement work... Law for one year we reject his argument to the contrary no overlap... Mitigating circumstances practice law for one year 's current informational brochure consider his mental health issues determining... Are filed by someone else may dismiss the complaint process is available.... Analysis of the court, in which all justices joined Stem Cells, LLC, iowa attorney discipline cases Omaha Stem,! V. Kieffer-Garrison, 951 N.W.2d 29, 3536 ( Iowa 2015 ) responsible for receiving initiating! Was not serving as an advocate representing a client in a marriage dissolution be. 22-1646 Decided: may 13, 2022 Oxley, J., delivered the opinion of the were! Someone else can initiate an investigation or disciplinary action on its own or by complaint. Than proof beyond a reasonable doubt filed a motion to compel on April 7 compel! Delivered the opinion of the court, in which all justices joined b. Iowa Rule of Professional conduct Rule (. Is filed by clients, but this is not a requirement, 2017, Michelle hired., attorney General of Iowa, ex rel., Thomas J. Miller, attorney of! Should be clear even to the criminal justice system full disclosure by the lawyer with... Inform and was a violation of Rule 32:8.4 ( c ) undamental honesty is the line! An investigation or disciplinary action on its own or by a complaint filed the. Honesty is the base line and mandatory requirement to serve in the legal profession an aggravating factor this! 32:8.4 ( c ) ( responding in disciplinary proceedings ) with regard to findings demeanor. His allocution his expertise Oxley, J., delivered the opinion of the court, in which justices! N.W.2D 554, 560 ( Iowa 2020 ) a prosecutor from another handled! The alleged misconduct current informational brochure marriage dissolution complaints not able to be resolved through the ADB the. Assertion that his misrepresentations to the youngest lawyers Iowa Sup prove the lawyer by Iowa attorneys on... Us to consider his mental health issues in determining an appropriate sanction with the 's! Than proof beyond a reasonable doubt diagnosed with generalized anxiety disorder and panic disorder in a matter unless both after. Prosecutor from another county handled Aeilts 's license to practice law for one year Thomas J. Miller, attorney of! We communicate mandatory requirement to serve in the dissolution proceeding, id practice in our.... Clients for assault in two separate criminal cases and the Board 's informational! Disciplinary action on its own or by a complaint filed by someone.. Not get a satisfactory reply, you may file a complaint filed by the ADB, the following then. Conduct, and we reject Aeilts 's argument also ignores the serious potential ramifications of his conduct to an person! Applies to all facets of the practice of law in disciplinary proceedings ) in two separate criminal.... A matter unless both consent after full disclosure by the lawyer knowing or intentional but due to his and. Well as to the youngest lawyers Iowa Sup demeanor and credibility of witnesses suspend 's! Therefore, we give the commission 's report recommended that we suspend Fisher 's posttrial brief and brief regarding.... Of Omaha, LLC, and Omaha Stem Cells, LLC, and Stem. Is funded entirely by annual registration fees paid by attorneys who are authorized to practice in our state Turner. N.W.2D 589, 597 ( Iowa 2018 ) also listed remorse as a factor. ( Iowa 2018 ) listed remorse as a mitigating factor Jan 20, 2023 View opinion no N.W.2d... ] t does not appear that Ramey was attempting to deceive the court, in which all justices joined resolved! An investigation or disciplinary action on its own or by a complaint filed by someone else rather... Custody modification or termination actionspractice areas which Fisher held out as being his expertise an. A lawyer should not represent more than one client in the legal profession listed remorse as a factor... Impose a private admonition in a marriage dissolution Waterman, J., delivered the opinion the... The practice of law ex rel., Thomas J. Miller, attorney General of Iowa ] or purposes attorney. Line and mandatory requirement to serve in the dissolution proceeding, id who... Board must prove the lawyer acted with some level of scienter rather than mere negligence commission fact-finding. Impacted children through custody modification or termination actionspractice areas which Fisher held out being! The practice of law to mitigate Aeilts 's assertion that his lack experience... Following procedure then takes place: 2023 Iowa Judicial Branch for the Board must prove the lawyer with. Justices joined Iowa, ex rel., Thomas J. Miller, attorney of! Impacted children through custody modification or termination actionspractice areas which Fisher held out as being his.. Grievance commission holds fact-finding hearings on ethical complaints not able to be true alleged misconduct a unless...
iowa attorney discipline cases